Thursday, April 12, 2007

Kurt Vonnegut: So It Goes

One of my absolute favorite authors, I was introduced to Vonnegut in seminary by my best mate, it was a nice break from all that crazy theology. God bless you Mr. Vonnegut.
So it goes

Wednesday, April 11, 2007

The Exalted Crucified Messiah: Conversion or Call?

In the third chapter of Gorman’s work on cruciformity he deals with many contentious issues of Pauline theology in an effort to explain how Paul could contend that the crucified Christ was synonymous with the living Lord.

Gorman does this by first examining Paul’s encounter with Jesus, taking up the debate in Pauline Theology of whether or not Paul’s experience on the road to Damascus constitutes a conversion experience or whether it is more appropriate to speak of it as a call to a new vocation (namely to be the apostle to the nations).

I have always tended to play up the call aspect of Paul’s Damascus experience, namely because he is still firmly embedded in Judaism, albeit a different sect so to speak. What I dislike most about calling Paul’s encounter with Jesus a conversion, is the modern introspective claims that are usually applied to such an encounter. In such a retelling Paul is made to look like a modern guilt ridden man, stuck in a legalistic religion trying to work his way to God, feeling empty and desperately trying to fill that God shaped hole in his heart, bam, he encounters the living Lord, and experiences true religion… Now this picture rarely comes up in scholarly discussions, but it does tend to find its way in to far too many pulpits.

Gorman does a good job navigating through this discussion, seeing Paul’s experience on the road to Damascus as both a conversion and a call (also seeing in it a commission). Following Alan Segal’s penetrating work he sees enough evidence to call Paul’s apocalyptic encounter with Jesus a true conversion (in the context of antiquity of course). He explains that this conversion is not from one religion to another, but rather from one sect to another. This helps to contextualize the term conversion to help correct those who see Paul finally converting to the ‘true’ God. For Paul his encounter with Jesus was not information to learn, but rather a claim to be embraced.

Gorman goes on to explain how this encounter continued to shape Paul’s theology and ministry. Elucidating another big controversy in Pauline theology, namely Schweitzer’s “in-Christ mysticism”...

Tuesday, April 10, 2007

The Influencers Survey

Here is a survey that I found at Jesus Creed (although I can't find it now) who found it via the Jesus Manifesto, so go ahead waste some time, and add this to your blog, leave a comment if you do here and at Jesus Creed.

“I’m interested in your perceptions of influence in contrast to those who have actually influenced you. Here’s how my little experiment will work. After each of the categories below, add people to the lists. If someone has already “taken your answer” add another “x”. Make sense? I’m assuming that some folks will add names to the list, but many others will agree…some folks will have lots of x-es after their names. [slightly edited; I’m a prof]

Once you’ve added to the list and posted on your site, please leave a comment here. I’ll try to keep the list updated. Oh, and please don’t list yourself or your own blog or your own community.”

Who do you think are the two most influential Christian spiritual leaders today (in North America)?

  1. Rick Warren
  2. Joel Osteen
  3. T.D. Jakes
  4. Joyce Meyers
  5. Jim Wallis x
  6. Bill Hybels
  7. Shane Claborne x

Who do you think are the two most influential emerging Christian spiritual leaders today (in North America)?

  1. Brian McLaren x
  2. Rob Bell
  3. Todd Hunter
  4. Tony Jones x

Which two Christian spiritual leaders (in North America) do you think are most worthy of being influential?

  1. Eugene Peterson x
  2. Ched Myers
  3. Rich Nathan
  4. Diana Butler Bass
  5. Jim Wallis
  6. Brian McLaren
  7. Rob Bell
  8. Richard Foster
  9. Stanley Hauerwas x

Which two churchy or theological blogs do you think are the most influential?

  1. The Jesus Creed x
  2. Real Live Preacher
  3. Tall Skinny Kiwi
  4. Jollyblogger
  5. God’s Politics
  6. Beliefnet.com
  7. AKMA's Random Thoughts x

Which two churchy or theological blogs have influenced you the most?

  1. Reclaiming the Mission
  2. Leaving Munster
  3. Internet Monk
  4. The Kinglings Muse
  5. Jesus Creed x
  6. Dylan’s Lectionary Blog
  7. Conversation at the Edge
  8. The God Hungry
  9. The Radical Pastor
  10. On Journeying with those in Exile x

Which two North American church communities do you believe are the most influential?

1. Willow Creek
2. Saddleback
3. Lifechurch.tv
4. Vineyard Columbus, Ohio

Which two self-described emerging/missional (North American) communities do you believe are the most influential?

  1. Solomon’s Porch x
  2. Mars Hill (take your pick)
  3. Imago Dei, Portland
  4. Vintage (Santa Cruz) x

Which two North American church communities do you think are most worthy of being influential?

  1. Church of the Savior (Washington, D.C.)
  2. A Catholic Worker house…take your pick
  3. Oscar Romero Catholic Worker, Oklahoma City
  4. Koinonia, Georgia
  5. Apostles Church, Seattle WA
  6. Vintage Faith
  7. St. Sabina (Chicago, IL)
  8. Mars Hill, MI
  9. the simple way, Philadelphia PA x
  10. Irving Bible Church
  11. Rutba House, NC x

Cruciformity: The Cruciform God (part 2)

On the basis of the Christ event, Paul infers not only the depth of human lostness . . . but also the depth of divine grace and love. . . . [God] does not wait until he can let the principle of poetic justice rule. Rather, according to Paul, his nature consists in re-creating the unlovely so that under his love they become lovely, in turning enemies into reconciled people, in giving worth to the worthless. This is the self characterization of the Father of Jesus.[1]

The section I found to be the most interesting in the first chapter was Gorman’s teasing out what it means to say that ‘God is for us’. Essentially God is for us because God loves us, and this love is God’s way of being, and it corresponds to the self giving love of Christ on the cross. Gorman explains this further by relating the relationship between God and Jesus to the proverb ‘like father, like son’. Its reflexive: if Jesus is like God, then God is like Jesus.

‘For Paul, there was a necessary ‘family resemblance’ between the Father and the Son. The Father was like the Son, and vice versa. If the Christ of Paul’s experience was the faithful, obedient Son of God, then he acted in life and especially in death according to the will and character of God. That is to say, the Son’s act on the cross was an act of ‘family resemblance’ of conformity to God. If so, Paul would have reasoned from his experience of Christ, God must be a God who by nature wills and does what the Son willed and did. God is, in other words, a god of self-giving love whose power and wisdom are found in the weakness and folly of the cross.’

The powerful implication for those who seek to follow the crucified One is that all praxis must now pass the test of conformity to the cross of Christ.



[1] Jürgen Becker, Paul: Apostle to the Gentiles, trans. O.C. Dean jr. (Louisville: Westminister/John Knox, 1993), 378-79.



Technorati tags: , , , ,

Monday, April 09, 2007

The Cruciform God: Chapter One (Part 1)

Gorman starts chapter one with a minor but very important point concerning the ‘new perspective’. He states that, ‘Knowing God – having an appropriately awe -filled yet intimate relationship, or partnership, with the creator, redeemer of Israel, and sovereign of the universe – is and was the life goal of faithful Jews.’

This is an important caveat in discussing Paul’s view of God, because often in such discussions where talk of Jesus and God take place it is the Jewish people and the Jewish God who are made into caricatures so as to show the greatness of the Christian god. Gorman takes pains to show what most biblical scholars concede, namely that Paul’s talk of God is within the scope of Judaism(s).

That caveat being made the purpose of this chapter is to show that for Paul, God and the cross were inextricably interrelated. It is not just Jesus who is defined by the cross, but also that God himself is defined by the cross.

Gorman argues this in a rather logical way (or perhaps linear is the better word here). Gorman sets up the reader with the understanding that Paul’s knowledge of God is shaped from beginning to end by Jewish categories. He does this by emphasizing the role of (a) the Shema (Deut 6.4) in Paul’s talk of God. (The Shema obviously focuses on the oneness of God) (b) the faithfulness of God to his promises (Rom 3.3-4), and (c) God as a relational God (Rom 1.8). Gorman offers plenty of proof from the Hebrew Scriptures to substantiate these claims about God, and elucidates the reader of how Paul used these same categories. Gorman then expands on point 1.c (God is relational) by focusing on Paul’s view of God as father, although there are places in the Hebrew Scriptures where God is seen as a father, Gorman makes the case that Paul is following Jesus’ own example here. Gorman expands this relational aspect by tying in the ‘Son of God’ tropes with Jesus’ own ‘Abba’ traditions, tying this in to the peculiar way in which Paul sees the followers of Jesus as children of God (obviously the rub here would be the fact that Paul included the Gentiles). Paul uses adoption language here to make his argument. This moves Gorman to his next position, namely that, God the father is for humanity.